From hidden back-street gems to the legendary butchers who have been feeding our city for generations, the passion for a perfect crust is clearly alive and well.
Whether it’s a classic pork pie for a Saturday match, a rich steak and ale to warm up a rainy Monday, or a modern gourmet take on the humble classic, you’ve pinpointed the absolute best of the best.
After sifting through hundreds of your nominations, including many we received through the Yorkshire Evening Post Facebook page, we’ve whittled it down to the top 11.
If you call yourself a pie lover and haven't ticked these off your list yet, you might have some dances left on your dance card for a trip to one of these reader-approved establishments.
1. The Pie Collective
This mobile sensation was the clear runaway winner. Known for their incredible pop-ups and catering, they have built a cult following for using high-quality local ingredients and serving up pies that readers described as "consistently tasty" and "phenomenal." 🥧 Address: 5 Wharfe Crescent, Pool in Wharfedale, Otley, LS21 1LU | Tony Johnson
2. Wilsons Butchers
A Leeds legend that needs no introduction. Whether it's the Cross Gates original or the Morley branch, the name Wilson's is synonymous with the "gold standard" of pork pies. Readers say they are simply a "local religion" that can't be beaten. 🥧 Address: 38 Austhorpe Road, Cross Gates, Leeds, LS15 8DX | Google Street View
3. Nigella's Cafe
Hailed as the home of the "perfect steak pie," Nigella’s in Morley has a loyal fan base who swear by its traditional fillings and flaky pastry. One reader noted they are "the medicine" you need on a cold day. 🥧 Address: 77 Queen Street, Morley, Leeds, LS27 8DX | Google Street View
4. Dave’s Pies & Ale
For those who like a side of craft beer with their crust, Dave’s on Kirkstall Road is the ultimate destination. Your feedback highlighted the "proper chunky meat fillings" and the perfect pairing with a rotating selection of real ales. 🥧 Address: 350 Kirkstall Road, Burley, Leeds, LS4 2HQ | Google Street View
5. Growlers of Pudsey
Pudsey residents are fiercely protective of Growlers. It’s a go-to for many Loiners specifically for their "banging" hot pies and the legendary meat and potato options that have fed the community for years. 🥧 Address: 161 Richardshaw Lane, Pudsey, LS28 6AA | Google Street View
6. Blake Henry’s Family Butchers
Rounding out the "Pudsey Powerhouses," Blake Henry’s received huge support for their traditional butchery approach. Readers specifically called out their lamb pies as some of the "best you will ever have." 🥧 Address: 8-10 Robin Lane, Pudsey, LS28 7BN | Google Street View