The Whites looked to be heading out in normal time following Mallik Wilks' fifth-minute strike only for Gjanni Alioski to equalise in the 92nd minute to take the game to spot kicks.
Yet United's joy and relief was shortlived and Graham Smyth, the YEP's chief football writer, hands out the scores.
13. Robbie Gotts
NA - Had Leeds' first shot on target and tried to add energy. Photo by Oli Scarff - Pool/Getty Images.
14. David Webb (referee)
6 - A bit fussy. Fell for some wily play from both sides which took fluency out of the game. Photo by Catherine Ivill/Getty Images
3 / 3